Casualty Reports

 
Close this window
 

CHAPTER SIX
Surgical, Medical, and Logistic Considerations

 

SURGERY AND THE WOUNDED

Information on surgical operations is fundamental knowledge for a variety of medico logistical problems. It points up the need for surgical specialists and for ancillary personnel. It indicates the need for plasma and whole blood and for preoperative and postoperative care. It forms the basis for staffing, supply, and for supporting requirements for committing surgical and evacuation hospitals as well. And those most in need of surgery establish the priority for swift evacuation of the wounded from the battlefield, since, in wartime, emergency surgery cannot be postponed with the same degree of freedom that might be applied to other medical support considerations, such as alternate methods of treatment or optional means of evacuation and hospitalization.

In Korea in 1950, hospital support was austere and adequate surgical care could not always be rendered in country, especially because of the shortage of highly qualified surgeons. Early evacuation of the wounded either before or after their surgery was necessary under the circumstances. Not until October 1951 were sufficient skilled surgeons available to enable the Eighth U.S. Army Surgeon to organize professional specialty teams (9). Despite these handicaps, U.S. Army patients received life-giving surgery in Korea and Japan along with other improved medical procedures to the extent that the case fatality rate for wounded achieved a new low of 2.5 percent compared to the 4.5 percent experienced in all of World War II.

When surgical operations are related to the number of wounded requiring surgery (table 75), and when surgery such as debridement of wounds is excluded, 59 percent (46,024) of the 77,788 admissions to medical treatment facilities required one or more surgical operation. There were 89,974 surgical operations performed, for an average of 1.2 operations per total wounded or an average of two surgical operations per wounded patient for whom an operation was performed. When the number of operations are considered by type of surgery performed, genitourinary surgery averaged 4.5 operations per wounded who received genitourinary surgery; oral surgery averaged three operations, and neurosurgery and gastrointestinal and abdominal surgery averaged slightly over two operations for these specialties. All other specified types of surgical operation averaged two operations or less. With regard to anatomical location of wound and surgical specialties associated with the various body regions, the thoracoabdominal region averaged 1.4 operations per total wounded with wounds of the thorax and abdomen, compared to one operation for each wounded of either the head, face or neck area, or of the upper or lower extremities combined. When the number of surgical operations are restricted to those who received the operations, the distribution is slightly different. Surgical specialties associated with wounded of the head, face and neck area for whom operations were performed, averaged 2.2 operations, those with thoracoabdominal wounds and operations were almost identical with an average 2.1 operations, and those with extremity wounds and surgical operations averaged 1.8 operations. Although plastic surgery was undoubtedly performed on such body regions as the head, face, neck, and the extremities, this specialty was not separately identified in this connotation, and only those surgical procedures classified as plastic surgery, "not elsewhere classified (n.e.c.)" were identified. Attesting to its magnitude, however, even this restricted classification shows an average of 1.7 operations per wounded for which plastic surgery "n.e.c." was recorded.

Table 76 shows the surgical specialties by type of operation performed separately for wounded division and non-division troops. Of the 46,024 wounded with one or more surgical operations, 43,803 (95.2 percent) were division troops and only 2,221 (4.8 percent) were non-division troops. This, of course, is added testimony to the constant, and immediate need for surgical hospital support of frontline divisions. Other than order of magnitude, there appear to be no marked differences between the distributions by type of specialty. However, there were slightly larger proportions of thoracic surgery,


84

Table 75.-Admissions for wounded in action and surgical operations, anatomical location and type of surgery, U.S. Army, Korea, July 1950-July 1953

Anatomical location
and type of surgery

Wounds

Number of
Operations

Average number
of operations

Number

With surgery

For admissions

For cases with operations

Number

%

Body region and type of surgery
77,788
46,024
59.2
89,974
1.2
2.0
Head, face, and neck
14,349
6,603
46.0
14,294
1.0
2.2

    Neurosurgery

(1)

1,659
11.6
3,984

(1)

2.4

    Eye, ear, nose, and throat

(1)

1,668
11.6
3,341

(1)

2.0

    Oral surgery

(1)

408
2.8
1,237

(1)

3.0

    General surgery, head and neck, not elsewhere classified

(1)

2,868
20.0
5,732

(1)

2.0
Thorax-abdomen
12,541
8,179
65.2
17,118
1.4
2.1

    Thoracic surgery

(1)

2,106
16.8
3,140

(1)

1.5

    Gastrointestinal and abdominal

(1)

1,827
14.6
4,148

(1)

2.3

    Genitourinary surgery

(1)

356
2.8
1,614

(1)

4.5

    General surgery, trunk, not elsewhere classified

(1)

3,890
31.0
8,216

(1)

2.1

Upper and lower extremities

50,489
26,668
52.8
48,787
1.0
1.8

    Orthopedic surgery

(1)

10,624
21.0
16,041

(1)

1.5

    General surgery, extremities, not elsewhere classified

(1)

16,044
31.8
32,746

(1)

2.0
Body generally
114

(1)

(1)

(1)

(1)

(1)

Anatomical location unknown
295

(1)

(1)

(1)

(1)

(1)

Plastic surgery, not elsewhere classified

(1)

3,118

(1)

5,327

(1)

1.7
All other surgery

(1)

1,456

(1)

4,448

(1)

3.1

    1Not applicable or data not available.

Table 76.- Admission for wounded in action with surgical operations, annual rates, and percent distribution, by type of surgery and type of unit, U.S. Army, Korea, July 1950-July 1953
[Rates stated as cases per year per 1,000 average strength]

Type of surgery

U.S. Army, Korea

Type of unit

Division

Non-division

Number

Rate

%

Number

Rate

%

Number

Rate

%

Total with surgery
46,024
71.81
100.0
43,803
132.20
100.00
2,221
7.18
100.0
Neurosurgery
1,659
2.58
3.6
1,559
4.71
3.6
100
0.32
4.5

    Brain and meninges

1,067
1.66
2.3
996
3.01
2.3
71
0.23
3.2

    Other neurosurgery

592
0.92
1.3
563
1.70
1.3
29
0.09
1.3
Eye, ear, nose, and throat
1,668
2.60
3.6
1,587
4.79
3.6
81
0.26
3.6
Oral surgery
408
0.64
0.9
374
1.13
0.9
34
0.11
1.5
General surgery, head and neck, not elsewhere classified
2,868
4.48
6.2
2,689
8.12
6.2
179
0.58
8.1
Thoracic surgery
2,106
3.28
4.6
2,030
6.13
4.6
76
0.25
3.4

    Heart, pericardium, and great vessels

27
0.04
0.1
27
0.08
0.1
0
--
--

    Other thoracic surgery

2,079
3.24
4.5
2,003
6.05
4.5
76
0.25
3.4
Gastrointestinal and abdominal
1,827
2.85
4.0
1,759
5.30
4.0
68
0.22
3.1

    Esophagus and stomach

52
0.08
0.1
48
0.14
0.1
4
0.01
0.2

    Other gastro-abdominal

1,775
2.77
3.9
1,711
5.16
3.9
64
0.21
2.9
Genitourinary surgery
356
0.56
0.8
344
1.04
0.8
12
0.04
0.5

    Kidney

93
0.15
0.2
93
0.28
0.2
0
--
--

    Other genitourinary

263
0.41
0.6
251
0.76
0.6
12
0.04
0.5
General surgery of trunk, not elsewhere classified
3,890
6.07
8.4
3,695
11.15
8.4
195
0.63
8.8
Orthopedic surgery
10,624
16.58
23.1
10,261
30.97
23.4
363
1.17
16.3
General surgery, extremities, not elsewhere classified
16,044
25.03
34.8
15,190
45.84
34.7
854
2.76
38.5
Plastic surgery, not elsewhere classified
3,118
4.87
6.8
2,893
9.00
6.8
135
0.44
6.1
All other surgery
1,456
2.27
3.2
1,332
4.02
3.0
124
0.40
5.6


85

Table 77.- Comparison of admissions excluded to total nonbattle admissions processed, by type of admission with surgical operation, U.S. Army, Korea, July 1950-December 1953

Type of admission

Admissions processed

All nonbattle causes

Disease

Nonbattle injury

U.S. Army, Korea, admissions
409,490
328,395
81,095
Number processed in surgery count
404,540
323,940
80,600
Number not included
4,950
4,455
495
Percent of admissions excluded
1.2
1.4
0.6
Non-division admissions
215,170
178,235
36,935

    Number processed in surgery count

210,220
173,780
36,440

    Number not included

4,950
4,455
495
Percent of admissions excluded
2.3
2.5
1.3

gastrointestinal and abdominal surgery, and orthopedic surgery among division troops, whereas non-division troops showed a slightly higher relative proportion of neurosurgery (brain and meninges) than did the division wounded. This latter situation may result from the chance of non-division seriously wounded receiving medical treatment in contrast to division seriously wounded surviving to reach medical care.


SURGERY AND NONBATTLE ADMISSIONS

Unfortunately, nonbattle admissions were not processed to the same degree of detail as were the battle admissions and, therefore, only the number of admissions in Korea with surgical operation recorded by type of operation is available. The number of procedures and the specialties required, identified by specific area or origin, as Japan-Korea, are not at hand. Another difficulty arose in processing the nonbattle admissions for total U.S. Amy, Korea, by type of unit. Some of the cases which would ordinarily fall into the non-division category (after all division cases were properly identified) were inadvertently omitted at the time of processing. The number involved was small, however, and amounted to about 1 percent of the total counts for nonbattle admissions in Korea during the period July 1950-Deceber 1953. Table 77 provides a comparison of the differences related to total U.S. Army, Korea, and to the non-division group to which they apply. Even when compared with the overall counts for non-division admissions in Korea, the excluded cases amount to about 2 percent of the total, a not too significant proportion for the introduction of bias.

Unlike the wounded where almost all of those requiring surgery originated in division units, the surgical requirements for nonbattle admissions were about even by type of unit (table 78). There were, however, slightly higher proportions of nonbattle injury admissions with surgery originating from divisions (57.5 percent,) and slightly, lower proportions of disease admissions with surgery from divisions (46.0 percent). The relative proportions were reversed for nonbattle admissions with, surgery from non-division units, being 42.5 percent of all nonbattle injury admissions with surgery in Korea and 54.0 percent of all disease admissions in Korea with surgery.

When the comparison is made within each type of unit rather than between units, the divisions showed 53.5 percent of their nonbattle admissions with surgery were due to disease and 46.5 percent were due to nonbattle injury. With the nonbattle admissions with surgery restricted to those originating in non-division units, 64.7 percent were due to disease and 35.3 percent were due to nonbattle injury. For total U.S. Army, Korea, the overall proportions with surgery were 59.0 percent, due to disease and 41.0 percent due to nonbattle injury.

Tables 79 slid 80 present information by type of unit, and type of surgical specialty for disease admissions with surgical operations and for nonbattle injury admissions with surgical operations, separately. Excluding the relatively higher proportions for oral surgery among division troops and relatively lower proportions for genitourinary surgery, there are no major differences between these two types of units for disease admissions with surgical operations. The two surgical specialties with the highest proportionate shares of disease operations were (1) gastrointestinal and abdominal, and (2) genitourinary surgery. Nonbattle injury, admissions with surgical operations show only very


86

Table 78.-Number and Percent of nonbattle admissions processed, by type of admission with surgical operation, U.S. Army, Korea, July 1950-December 1953

Type of admission

Admissions processed

All nonbattle causes

Disease

Nonbattle injury

U.S. Army, Korea
404,540
323,940
80,600
Admissions with surgery
56,400
33,325
23,165
Percent with surgery
14.0
10.3
28.7
Percent with surgery by type of admission
100.0
59.0
41.0
Division
194,320
150,160
44,160

    Admissions with surgery

28,645
15,315
13,330

    Percent with surgery

14.7
10.2
30.2

    Percent with surgery by type of admission

100.0
53.5
46.5

    Percent with surgery by type of unit

50.7
46.0
57.5
Non-division
210,220
173,780
36,440

    Admissions with surgery

27,845
18,010
9,835

    Percent with surgery

13.2
10.4
27.0

    Percent with surgery by type of admission

100.0
64.7
35.3

    Percent with surgery by type of unit

49.3
54.0
42.5

slight variations between division and non-division troops for oral surgery, thoracic surgery, genitourinary surgery, and plastic surgery. The highest proportions are concentrated in orthopedic surgery and general surgery of the extremities. In terms of nonbattle admissions, with operations per 1,000 average strength per year, disease admissions with an operation rate of 52 per 1,000 exceed those for nonbattle injury of 36 per 1,000 per year. For disease, the non-division troops are highest with a rate, of 58 per 1,000 per year compared to 46 per 1,000 for divisions. On the other hand, the nonbattle injury admissions with operations show the highest annual rate (40 per 1,000) among the division troops with non-divisions amounting to only 32 per 1,000.

Table 79.- Admissions for disease with surgical operations, annual rates, and percent distribution, by type of surgery and type of unit, U.S. Army, Korea, July 1950-December 1953
[Rates stated as cases per year per 1,000 average strength]

Type of surgery

U.S. Army Korea

Type of unit

Division

Non-division

Number Rate % Number Rate % Number Rate %
Total with surgery
33,325
52.00
100.0
15,315
46.22
100.0
18,010
58.19
100.0
Neurosurgery
605
0.94
1.8
220
0.66
1.4
385
1.24
2.1
Brain and meninges
85
0.13
0.2
25
0.07
0.1
60
0.19
0.3
Other neurosurgery
520
0.81
1.6
195
0.59
1.3
325
1.05
1.8
Eye, ear, nose, and throat
2,330
3.64
7.0
980
2.96
6.4
1,350
4.36
7.5
Oral surgery
2,035
3.18
6.1
1,145
3.46
7.5
890
2.88
4.9
General surgery, head and neck, not elsewhere classified
1,130
1.76
3.4
505
1.52
3.3
625
2.02
3.5
Thoracic surgery
435
0.68
1.3
195
0.59
1.2
240
0.78
1.3
Heart, paricardium, and great vessels
5
0.01
0.0
5
0.02
0.0
0
0
0
Other thoracic surgery
430
0.67
1.3
190
0.57
1.2
240
0.78
1.3
Gastrointestinal and abdominal
10,475
16.34
31.4
4,925
14.86
32.2
5,550
17.93
30.8
Esophagus and stomach
85
0.13
0.2
55
0.16
0.4
30
0.10
0.2
Other gastro-abdominal
10,390
16.21
31.2
4,870
14.70
31.8
5,520
17.93
30.6
Genitourinary surgery
5,970
9.32
17.9
2,210
6.67
14.4
3,760
12.15
20.9
Kidney
105
0.16
0.3
65
0.20
0.4
40
0.13
0.2
Other genitourinary
5,865
9.16
17.6
2,145
6.47
14.0
3,720
12.02
20.7
General surgery of trunk, not elsewhere classified
1,500
2.34
4.5
655
1.98
4.3
845
2.73
4.7
Orthopedic surgery
1,435
2.24
4.3
665
2.01
4.3
770
2.49
4.3
General surgery, extremities, not elsewhere classified
3,320
5.18
10.0
1,635
4.93
10.7
1,685
5.44
9.4
Plastic surgery, not elsewhere classified
140
0.22
0.4
40
0.12
0.3
100
0.32
0.6
All other surgery
3,950
6.16
11.9
2,140
6.46
14.0
1,810
5.85
10.0


87

Table 80.- Admissions for nonbattle injury with surgical operations, annual rates, and percent distribution, by type of surgery and type of unit, U.S. Army, Korea, July 1950-December 1953
[Rates stated as cases per year per 1,000 average strength]

Type of surgery U.S. Army, Korea Type of unit
Division Non-division,
Number Rate % Number Rate % Number Rate %
Total with surgery
23,165
36.15
100.0
13,330
40.23
100.0
9,835
31.77
100.0
Neurosurgery
270
0.42
1.1
170
0.51
1.3
100
0.32
1.0
Brain and meninges
166
0.26
0.7
80
0.24
0.6
85
0.27
0.9
Other neurosurgery
105
0.16
0.4
90
0.27
0.7
15
0.05
0.1
Eye, ear, nose, and throat
1,210
1.89
5.2
635
1.92
4.8
575
1.86
5.8
Oral surgery
495
0.77
2.1
210
0.63
1.6
285
0.92
2.9
General surgery, head and neck, not elsewhere classified
1,660
2.59
7.2
805
2.43
6.0
855
2.76
8.7
Thoracic surgery
210
0.33
0.9
85
0.26
0.6
125
0.41
1.3
Heart, pericardium, and great vessels
5
0.01
0.0
0
--
0
5
0.02
0.1
Other thoracic surgery
205
0.32
0.9
85
0.26
0.6
120
0.39
1.2
Gastrointestinal and abdominal
345
0.54
1.5
200
0.60
1.5
145
0.47
1.5
Esophagus and stomach
20